Tuesday, October 30, 2007

The Truth About Student Loan Default Rates

By Richard Vedder

The Education Sector is one of the better research organizations dealing with higher education issues—I’m told it is tied, loosely, with the Democratic Party, which, if true, speaks highly of that group, something you will seldom hear from me. As my sidekick, Bryan O'Keefe, pointed out in his recent blog, the Democrats seem more engaged in higher education issues than the Republicans -- which is a shame for both the GOP and the country.

A recent analysis by Erin Dillon of the Education Sector explodes the myth that loans are not a big deal --a myth strengthened by Department of Education data, which reports the overall student loan default rate is under 5 percent. That number is simply baloney --worse than worthless. The Education Department looks at two year default rates --and most persons default after the second year.

Ms. Dillon looks at extended longitudinal data reaching back into the 1990s and finds much higher default rates -- rates that vary enormously depending on race/ethnicity, size of loan obligations, and post-college earnings. For example, the long term black (non-Hispanic) default rate appears to be around 39 percent, roughly ten times as great as that for Asians (4 percent) --the white non-Hispanic rate is about 7 percent. Similarly, those with $15,000 or more in loans had well over double the default rate (19 vs. 7 percent) of those with $5,000 or less in loans.

Moreover, with rising loan obligations, the default problem is almost certainly going to rise. This is aggravated by another trend that college presidents should be frightened about -- the college-high school earnings differential is NOT growing for women (for a decade), and may be slowing for men. The ability to pay off loans is directly related to post-college earnings, as the Education Sector study makes amply clear.

Here is my read on things. The unsustainable tuition fee explosion has been sustained for longer than expected by the introduction of student loans of ever greater magnitude. The notion, previously novel and suspect, is now conventional wisdom: college is a financial investment, and borrowing to pay for that investment is acceptable and prudent. However, as loan obligations rise relative to post-college incomes, the whole go-go financing becomes more suspect and potentially destabilizing, not only to individual borrowers, but to the American economy at large. The solution is to curb both student loans and the rate of tuition inflation. Until the colleges change their ways and governmental subsidies become more moderate, things are likely to get worse rather than better. We are paying a price for the inefficiencies of colleges that may become glaringly more obvious as the student loan repayment problem grows.


Rhett said...

Cohort default rates aren't worthless. In fact, they are a very useful indicator when used to assess the school's ability to ensure the borrower understands the obligations that come with a student loan. They are not intended to demonstrate the health of the student loan program and to compare the two is like comparing the effectiveness of a hammer to a paintbrush. The purpose of the cohort default rate is to identify the population of borrowers that are most at risk for default - those that disappear and never make a single payment. In many of these cases, the borrowers claim they were unaware that they owed money - or perhaps they didn't think they had to pay the money back because they dropped out. Either way, we use cohort defaults to identify issues in the admissions office, financial aid office, and business office. Use the right tool for the job and you'll see that everything makes a little more sense.

Patriot said...

Interesting article. We are looking for talented writers like you at articlesaboutloans.com ..Share you expertise with others and earn ad revenue share.



Poly Muthumbi said...

When I think of defaulted student loans, I get vexed because I would not like to fall prey to this embarrassing scenario, not for one second! Defaulted Student Loans can get you so devastated that it irks for the rest of your life. Yet it may not be your willpower for it to happen. It may have been an unavoidable reason, like problems at home or incapacitation. But then you can not ignore the fact that some of us disregard responsibilities to pay for the student loans and as a result keep a bad credit history.

Poly Muthumbi is a Web Administrator and Has Been Researching and Reporting on Student Loan Consolidation for Years. For More Information on Student Loan Consolidation, Visit Her Site at DEFAULTED STUDENT LOANS

kitten said...

At age 29, I find myself in default. It's a horrible place to be...it's the unknown shamed world where there is no support or information....

kitten said...

At age 29, I find myself in default. It's a horrible place to be...it's the unknown shamed world where there is no support or information....

Anonymous said...

I have been reading your blog. I thought it's nice blog.

repayment student loan
loans for student

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the good information.

private student loan credit
student loans help
paying student loans
student education loans
bad credit for student loans
pay student loan
government pay student loans
student college loan
pay student loans
repayment student loan
private bad credit student loans
pay off student loan
student loans with bad credit
loan for student
national student loan centre
loans for student
student loans rate
student loans for students
student loans for bad credit
loans for college students
fixed rate student loan
student loans rates
college students loans