Thursday, October 08, 2009

Student Employment Builds Character

by Daniel L. Bennett

Full disclosure: I am a former student of Dr. Kalenkoski and she served as my primary master's thesis advisor (for which I am very thankful).

A few weeks ago, Dr. Vedder wrote a blog about new research by economists Charlene Kalenkoski and Sabrina Wulff Pabiloniaon that suggests that college students, on average, work while in school for spending money, rather than to pay tuition, and that hours worked does not hinder academic performance, but may in fact, improve it up to a certain amount. Today, this research was one of Inside Higher Ed's top stories. Dr. Kalenkoski was quoted as saying, "“We’re not saying there aren’t students who work to pay much of their tuition, we’re just saying it’s more likely they’re taking out loans to make up for whatever isn’t covered by other kinds of financial aid or parents.”

I believe that the authors of the study are on to something here that speaks of the affect that student loans are having on not only tuition (which my colleague discusses here), but on student's attitude toward work and study.

Having maintained at least a part-time job for most of my academic career, I can provide anecdotal evidence to support the author's findings. I was fortunate enough to qualify for federal grants and to have been awarded several scholarships to cover the bulk of tuition fees (attending a regional campus of Ohio University for 2 years reduced this cost substantially), so my work earnings from delivering pizza and frying chicken wings as an undergraduate, were not used to pay tuition, but rather to make a car and insurance payment, pay rent and utilities, and incidental expenses (including 'beer money'). I generally worked an average of 20-30 hours per week during the school year, while maintaining a 3.8+GPA as a "full-time student" --which effectively made a 4-year degree into 5-year one.

Lacking an abundance of free time outside of the classroom and work, I had to use my time wisely to complete projects and study for exams. Admittedly, I missed out on much of the social atmosphere that many college students enjoy for the the first several years of college because of employment. This is one of the primary reasons that I decided to study abroad my junior year and not work during my senior year of college, and instead opted to take out student loans to cover the "unmet" out-of-pocket expenses. The extra time generated from not having to work was definitely not replaced with an increase in study time, although my grades remained approximately constant and I did participate in more campus activities, including becoming a patron of the many fine Court Street establishments. It was enjoyable, but looking back, I would have been better off to have worked a part-time job to cover my expenses rather than taking on as much student debt. Hindsight is 20/20.

During my tenure as a master's student, I was fortunate enough to receive a graduate assistantship that was accompanied by full tuition funding and a stipend, in exchange for 16 hours of work for the department's graduate program director -who did not by any means allow his assistant a walk in the park. As graduate-level work is much more intensive than undergraduate, this left me with very little time for campus activities. As a somewhat older returning student, I was much less interested in this aspect of college and spent any free time with my girlfriend (soon to be wife) and/or our close group of friends -not engaging in destructive behavior might I add. The limited amount of free time, coupled with an appreciation for serious academic study that was gained from a few years in the "real world", helped me to remain focused and perform academically better than any other time in my life. And honestly, this was a much more enjoyable life experience that resulted in an abundance more of life takeaway than those last 2 years of the more social undergraduate study.

My experience supports the above author's findings that student employment does not seriously hinder academic performance (it may actually improve it) and that student earnings from employment may not necessarily be used to pay tuition. Reflecting on my own time in college, I am a strong proponent for student employment, as it builds important life skills (e.g. time management, discipline and appreciation for the opportunity to get an education) that many college students lack these days --something that is evident from employer complaints about graduates. Previous generations of college students epitomized the "starving college student" picture, and were often forced to work jobs and live a modest lifestyle in order to pursue a college education. Much of that meritorious tradition has been lost in the modern age, as many now feel entitled to not only a college education, but high marks that may be undeserved. We've allowed college to became a tool for socialization and entertainment, as opposed to a tool for lifelong learning. Easy loan policy by the government has definitely been an enabler of this shift in paradigm.


capeman said...

Ah, the wonderboy received generous scholarships, partook of federal loans, studied at a subsidized state university (including special regional campuses intended no doubt largeley to help the non-well-to-do), did study abroad, took 5 years to get the undergraduate degree, did a masters degree, again at a state university, got free tuition and stipend for 16 hrs. work per week -- not a walk in the park, we are assured!

And now the wonderboy apparently has a new career with the Doc's outfit, which specializes in bashing public education, federal loans, complaining about students who goof around in college too long, pushing online education, for-profit "universities", trashing research (like that master's program? like the research of the wonderboy's professor that is being plugged today?)

Am I missing something? Or are these people completely clueless?

Anonymous said...

"Am I missing something? Or are these people completely clueless?"

Sounds like the clueless one is you.

I too worked summers and did work-study at school. I think it improved by attitude towards school because you are reminded every time you work what your education will help you avoid - low-wage menial labor.

As for your complaints about his current activities - YOU ARE ENGAGING IN A LOGICAL FALLACY of an ad hominem type.

When I signed my student loan form it didnt have a box that says "I promise to never criticize this program." Same with my degree and my University. Neither did the blog author. If you dont realize that there is massive waste in higher ed, even though many fine students get good educations out of them (thanks to large public subsidies, high tuitions, and massive Federal aid), and that there could be better ways to do it, you are not paying attention.

capeman said...

Freedom's Truth (are you another one of those libertarian types who accepts state-subsidized education and sees no irony?) -- Methinks the wonderboy needs to walk the walk, not just talk the Doc's trash talk.

I could understand if he decided his bachelor's degree was wasting enough time and (other people's) money, and then decided he'd had enough of the higher education racket.

But then going on for a graduate degree -- again, at one of the despised public universities -- praising his thesis advisor's research -- and again, getting free tuition plus a stipend for 16 hrs. work per week -- all the while criticizing the waste in higher education (yeah, maybe he should have had to work 40 hrs a week for what he got!) -- this strikes me as a bit much.

Again, this strikes me as a high level of cluelessness. Or at least hypocrisy.

I think in this case, the student employment (which in general, I don't criticize) did not build much self-reflectiveness, or character.

If you're going to patronize the whorehouse (figuratively speaking, a little crude, but after all the Doc was the one here who compared professors to whores), don't get too huffy about the indignity of it all after you're done. Or the cost.

University said...

This is a great reading. Thanks for the post. we have audience that like to read this kind of posts. we will add this to our site. I have a suggestion for a great site that helps to provide all the information about college and university for the higher academic study for the better career so that the aspirants will able to get proper information regarding their career and studies.Thanking you. college jobs

Anonymous said...

Thanks a lot for a bunch of good tips. I look forward to reading more on the topic in the future. Keep up the good work! This blog is going to be great resource. Love reading it.
good term paper-essay writing help